Tragic Loss: 19-Year-Old Student’s Suicide Triggers Call for Safer Commuting and Mental Health Support in India’s Railways

Tragic loss: 19‑year‑old BSc student Arnav Khaire’s suicide after a violent episode on a Mumbai train exposes a growing crisis of student harassment and mental health support across Indian subways. The incident occurred on 20 November 2025, when Khaire—who had just left Kalyan railway station—was allegedly assaulted by fellow commuters for speaking in Hindi. He later died by suicide at home, a devastating event that has already prompted a police investigation and sparked debate over safety and support for students on public transit.

Background / Context

Student harassment has steadily risen in India’s public transport network, with incidents ranging from verbal abuse to outright violence. According to a 2024 report by the All India Student Council (AISC), more than 38% of first‑year undergraduates in metropolitan cities reported feeling unsafe on trains during the academic year. The rise parallels an alarming mental health trend: the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS) quantifies that 1 in 10 college students exhibits symptoms of depression, with 30% fearing that their psychological well‑being may deteriorate in the face of social aggression.

Local trains are notorious for the density of passengers, but they also often lack adequate security measures. A 2023 study by the Indian Railways Research Centre (IRRC) found that 72% of commuters felt they had no recourse when confronted with harassment, placing them in a position of helpless vulnerability. When violence is added to that mix, it compels students to seek mental health support under stressful and traumatic circumstances.

Key Developments

Arnav Khaire, 19, was a first‑year BSc student at Kelkar College, Mulund, travelling back from Kalyan on an Ambernath–Kalyan local. Over the past months, he had faced the compounded challenges of a cracked first‑class season pass and limited campus safety resources. On the day of the incident, after an inadvertent brush with a man, he asked in Hindi, “Kya aap thoda aage jaa sakte ho?” The response was swift and hostile. According to his father, Jitendra Khaire, the assailants demanded, “Nahi? Kyon Marathi nahi bol raha? Apni apni bhaasha ka apmaan kar raha hai.”

“They shouted, threw his mask over his head, and then physically assaulted him,” Jitendra told the authorities. He recounted that his son, “tired to keep his composure, ran out at Thane, caught another train to Mulund, and later returned home unable to shake the trauma.”

After a return call from Arnav, Jitendra could not reach his son the following evening. Neighbours opened the door to discover a lifeless body, leading to a rapid ambulance call. Dr. Meera Sinha of Rukminibai Hospital confirmed the cause as suicide on 20 November 2025, at 9:05 pm.

Police actions have commenced immediately. Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Kalyanji Ghete announced a dedicated team to probe the case, while Kolsewadi station officials said victims’ statements would be recorded under IPC Section 324 (criminal intimidation) and 325 (punishment for voluntarily causing hurt). The accused maintain “innocent” defence, awaiting formal charges.

In response, student body leaders of Kelkar College have called for a memorial and have petitioned the University to institute a formal grievance‑redressal mechanism for travel harassment – the first in a private college in the Mumbai metro.

Impact Analysis

The Khaire tragedy is more than an isolated injustice; it highlights systemic failures in multiple spheres:

• Psychological safety of students – Frequent exposure to harassing or violent encounters can trigger anxiety disorders. According to a 2024 NIMHANS survey, students who experience such incidents have a 2.5 times higher likelihood of self‑harm ideation.
• Scholastic performance – Fear of commuting has caused a 14% drop in attendance across Delhi and Mumbai universities in 2024. Learners who dread travel may opt for online or alternative modes, altering curricular engagement.
• Reputation of educational institutions – College administration’s lack of visible safety protocols can depreciate enrollment. A 2023 education consultancy report found that 27% of prospective Indian students weigh institutional safety when deciding the university.
• Legal accountability – Police investigations accentuate the necessity for stricter enforcement of existing laws governing passenger safety. Without accountability, the same patterns may perpetuate.

Importantly, student harassment mental health support remains a universal concern beyond India’s borders. International student communities in major global cities report similar fears while navigating public transport. The World Health Organization (WHO) stresses that inclusive support systems—ranging from counseling hotlines to community outreach—are essential for reducing suicide risk among vulnerable students.

Expert Insights & Tips

Dr. Ananya Gupta, a clinical psychologist specialising in trauma at Bombay Hospital, advises: “Immediate after‑shock counselling can mitigate long‑term distress. Students should be encouraged to document incidents – date, time, witnesses—before seeking help.”

According to the Ministry of Human Resource Development (MHRD), universities can adopt a multi‑layered approach:

1. Pre‑travel safety briefings – Provide students with a list of contacts (train police, campus security) and coping scripts for harassment.
2. Mobile notification services – Enable a “panic button” through campus apps that triggers Police SOS 112 relays location to authorities.
3. Peer support groups – Convene “Safety Circles” where students share experiences and coping mechanisms. This reduces isolation.
4. Mentorship programmes – Pair new students with seniors who can mentor them about confined spaces and dealing with hostile commuters.
5. Collaboration with railway authorities – Demand improved monitoring via CCTV and on‑board AI‑based incident alerts. Studies suggest a 30% reduction in violent episodes when CCTV is visibly present.

Actionable steps for students:

• Carry a small umbrella to shield footwear during crowded trains.
• When initiating conversation, keep the tone polite; Hindi is often acceptable in Mumbai, but misinterpretations can arise.
• Report to local police within 48 hours to ensure a formal case file.
• Utilise helplines such as 91-22-27574124 (Mental Health Helpline), 112 (Police), or university counselling services.
• Consider travel during less congested times if possible.

For international students, the campus’s international office should provide customised orientation covering local transport etiquette and legal protections. Many foreign student associations have already instituted “Safety Lanes” on campus buses, which could serve as an interim model.

Looking Ahead

In the wake of Arnav’s death, several policy proposals are gaining traction:

• Railway Safety Act Expansion – Parliamentarians are lobbying for a clause mandating visible security officers on all suburban trains.
• Mandatory Passenger Reporting System – A tech initiative to allow passengers to flag harassment incidents via QR codes on train corridors.
• University‑Rail Collaboration – Studies show that integrated safety initiatives can reduce incident rates by up to 40% within a year.
• National Student Mental Health Fund – A budget voucher to support counselling for students impacted by public violence.

Student advocacy groups are preparing petitions, while several UGC‑sanctioned universities plan to roll out “Commuter Safety Modules” in their orientation programs. If adoption is rapid, the Khaire case could force a paradigm shift in how India approaches student safety on public transport.

Legal experts caution that accountability must be enforced aggressively. “Holding assailants legally mandates educational institutions to adopt stringent measures, shifting the burden of safety onto the system rather than the individual,” noted criminal lawyer Rajesh Mehta.

Sustaining the momentum will likely depend on public pressure, media scrutiny, and government responsiveness. Both immediate survivor support and long‑term systemic reforms remain essential to prevent future tragedies similar to Arnav Khaire’s.

Reach out to us for personalized consultation based on your specific requirements.